I repeated that same mistake yesterday, but this time, I did lose money.
I was doing some research to find deals, and quickly landed on a item promising 30,000,000 return. I got greedy, and decided to go for a quick sale, rather than do my due diligence. I flew 5 systems out, picked up the lot, and flew it back to Jita. Just in time for the Jita price to collapse. At this point, I'm looking at a 4,000,000 to 5,000,000 loss.
What did I do wrong?
- I did not pay attention to historical price. The selling price for this item was 5,600,000 at the time I purchased the initial lot. However, this item normally trades at 4,800,000, which is also the price I paid.
- I did not look at the profit margin, only the net absolute profit. The margin was a paltry 11% (after broker's fees and sales tax), which doesn't give me much room to manoeuvre if I get into a pricing war.
- I invested about 1/3 of my total cash in this lot. A fair chuck of my ISK is now tied up in goods that aren't selling.
- I didn't look at volume. 75-150 units of this item move a day in The Forge region, with the occasional spike in the 300 range. My lot represents a fair portion of that, so it's not likely that I'll be able to sell it quickly.
Lessons Learned
- Always check historical prices to see if you're not dealing with an item that's seeing a temporary spike in sales. If the spike is upward, don't invest. If the spike is downward, then it may be worth spending money on it. I think a good checklist of things to verify would be a good thing.
- Always calculate margins, to see how much room you have to adjust prices. This is the margin of security concept real world investors like Warren Buffett talk about, and it's a rule I've very familiar with. I totally ignored this rule yesterday.
- Diversify. I was reading Full Disclosure, and saw that Vincent has a large number of items for sale. I think this could help offset losses if you're wrong about a deal or if you run in a one-time negative event. Also, you don't have all your cash tied up in one item. I don't know what the proper limit is though. Maximum 5% available cash? Maximum 10% if it's a really good deal?
- Always compare historical volume to current volume on the market.
I also need to figure out how to deal with under-cutters. It's very draining to have to reset prices constantly.
A checklist eh? Sounds like a good idea but beware the bloated process. Make sure you keep your checklist short and cover the basics. We all know what can happen if the process takes over - no more innovation.
ReplyDeleteEven when you are following the innovation checklist:-)